An ethics perspective to South Africa’s civilian intelligence governance regime
Main Article Content
The role of national security entities in public administration, with specific reference to civilian intelligence structures, is a public policy issue of concern and interest across the globe, particularly with regard to questions of governance and public accountability. Governments need intelligence services to serve national and/or political interests, but these must, by nature, operate in conditions of secrecy. The gap between these two elements can be a source of misgovernance and/or abuse of power. We argue that the credibility of South African intelligence structures has been negatively impacted by failures and omissions of accountable governance since the emergence of a democratic dispensation in 1994. In particular, the article focuses on the effects of politicisation on effective governance of the country’s intelligence function. We propose an ethical governance model, framed by a transformative approach and grounded in ethical stewardship, as a way to give effect to constitutionally defined expectations regarding the purpose and management of the country’s intelligence function.
Auditor-General of South Africa. (2021, March 31). Auditor-General calls on government leaders to ensure “sustainable” audit outcomes. (Media Statement). https://www.agsa.co.za/Portals/0/Reports/PFMA/201920/2021%20PFMA%20 Media%20Release%20FINALISED%202.pdf [Accessed 10-08-2021].
Auditor-General of South Africa. (2018). Public Audit Amendment Act 5 of 2018. Pretoria, SA: Government Printers.
Augé, B. (2019). (2009, December). Angola under Joao Lourenço: Who Are the New Players of MPLA State? Notes de lÍfri, Ifri,. https://www.ifri.org/ sites/default/files/atoms/files/auge_angola_under_joao_lourenco_2019.pdf [Accessed 04-09-2021].
Balfour, E. (2021, January 27). Ms K describes ‘separate and discrete’ SSA command structure to protect Zuma. The Mail & Guardian. https://mg.co.za/ politics/2021-01-27-ms-k-describes-seperate-and-discrete-ssa-command- structure-to-protect-zuma/ [Accessed 23-03-2021].
Ball, N., & Fayemi, J. K. (Eds.). (2004). Security-Sector governance in Africa: A Handbook [E-book]. http://www.gsdrc.org/docs/open/gfn-ssr- securitysectorgovernanceinafrica-ahandbook.pdf [Accessed 09-08-2021].
Bellaby, R.W. (2011). What’s the harm? The ethics of intelligence collection. (Doctoral thesis, Aberystwyth University, Wales). Available from https://asset- pdf.scinapse.io/prod/2150271895/2150271895.pdf [Accessed 07-08-2021].
Bendix, D., & Stanley, R. (2008). Security sector reform in Africa: The promise and the practice of a new donor approach. African Centre for the Constructive Resolution of Disputes (ACCORD), Occasional Paper Series, 3(2), 1–58. https:// media.africaportal.org/documents/op_2008_2.pdf
Born, H., Johnson, L. K., & Leigh, I. (2005). Who’s watching the spies? Establishing intelligence service accountability. Potomac Books.
Botha, T. (2021, August 9). President Ramaphosa’s Cabinet reshuffle removes the cancerous prostate gland after the infected cells have spread. Daily Maverick. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2021-08-09-president- ramaphosas-cabinet-reshuffle-removes-the-cancerous-prostate-gland-after- the-infected-cells-have-spread/ [Accessed 09-08-2021].
Brock, J. E. C. (2016, May 4). How Zuma, the smiling spy, controls South Africa. U.S. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-safrica-zuma-insight-idUSKCN0XV1RB
Caldwell, C., & Karri, R. (2005). Organizational Governance and Ethical Systems: A Covenantal Approach to Building Trust. Journal of Business Ethics, 58, 249– 259. https://www.researchgate.net/deref/http%3A%2F%2Fdx.doi.org%2F10.1 007%2Fs10551-005-1419-2
Caldwell, C., Hayes, L. A., Karri, R., & Bernal, P. (2008). Ethical stewardship – Implications for leadership and trust. Journal of Business Ethics, 78(1), 153– 164. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9320-1
Caldwell, C., Karri, R., & Vollmar, P. (2006). Principal theory and principle theory: Ethical governance from the follower’s perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, 66(2–3), 207–223. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-5586-y
Cillers, J. (2021, July). South Africa’s security sector is in a crisis – reform must start now. https://issafrica.org/iss-today/south-africas-security-sector-is-in- crisis-reform-must-start-now
Coglianese, C. (2010). Presidential control of administrative agencies: A debate over law or politics? Journal of Constitutional Law, 12(2), 637–649.https://scholarship. law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1972&context=faculty_scholarship
Conley, R. S. (2003, February). The department of homeland security and the dual politics of reorganization: Presidential pre-emption, agency restructuring, and congressional challenges. In: The Presidency, Congress, and the War on Terrorism: Scholarly Perspectives, Gainsville, Florida.
Cowan, K. (2019, July 5). SARS and the “rogue” unit: the ultimate guide. Fin24. https://www.news24.com/fin24/economy/sars-and-the-rogue-unit-the- ultimate-guide-20190705
Coyne, J., Bell, P., & Merrington, S. (2013). Exploring ethics in intelligence and the role of leadership. International Journal of Business and Commerce, 2(10), 27–37. https://eprints.qut.edu.au/60718/
Daley, S. (1998, April 7). South African military chief quits over false coup report. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/1998/04/07/world/south- african-military-chief-quits-over-false-coup-report.html
De Colle, S., & Werhane, P. H. (2007). Moral Motivation Across Ethical Theories: What Can We Learn for Designing Corporate Ethics Programs? Journal of Business Ethics, 81(4), 751–764. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9545-7
Department of Justice and Constitutional Development. (South Africa) (a). (2021, January 26). The Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture, Corruption and Fraud in the Public Sector, including Organs of State. Day 331: The Commission will continue to hear State Security Agency (SSA) related evidence from the Acting Director-General at the State Security Agency (SSA), Mr Loyiso Jafta at 10h00. https://www.statecapture.org.za/site/hearings/date/2021/1/26
Department of Justice and Constitutional Development. (South Africa) (b). (2021, May 12). The Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture, Corruption and Fraud in the Public Sector, including Organs of State. Day 393: The Commission will also hear State Security Agency (SSA) related evidence from the Inspector General of Intelligence, Dr Setlhomamaru Dintwe, at 10h00 on Wednesday, 12 May 2021. https://www.statecapture.org.za/site/ hearings/date/2021/5/12 [Accessed 09-08-2021].
Department of Planning Monitoring and Evaluation. (South Africa). (2014, March 11). Twenty Year Review South Africa 1994-2014. https://www.poa. gov.za/news/Pages/Twenty%20Year%20Review%20South%20Africa%20 1994%20to%202014.aspx
Dlodlo(a), A. Minister Ayanda Dlodlo: State Security Agency Dept Budget Vote 2019/20, (2019, July 18). https://www.gov.za/speeches/minister-state-security-ms- ayanda-dlodlo-18-jul-2019-0000
Dlodlo(b), A. ‘State security develops ethics framework.’ SAnews, (2019, July 18). https://www.sanews.gov.za/south-africa/state-security-develops-ethics- framework
Dolley, C. (2018, May 10). EXCLUSIVE: Zuma’s mystery meeting with South African spook murdered in Serbia. News24. https://www.news24.com/ news24/SouthAfrica/News/exclusive-zumas-mystery-meeting-with-south- african-spook-murdered-in-serbia-20180510
Duncan, J. (2021, August 29). Centralising intelligence in the presidency comes with major risks. TimesLIVE. https://www.timeslive.co.za/sunday- times/opinion-and-analysis/2021-08-29-centralising-intelligence-in-the- presidency-comes-with-major-risks/
Du Plessis, C. (2021, February 2). DA’s Steenhuisen wants Ramaphosa to explain his role in the ANC's cadre deployment policy. News24. https://www.news24. com/news24/southafrica/news/das-steenhuisen-wants-ramaphosa-to- explain-his-role-in-the-ancs-cadre-deployment-policy-20210202
Ensor, L. (2021, February 17). State Security Agency officials reject obligation to disclose financial interests. BusinessLIVE. https://www.businesslive.co.za/ bd/national/2021-02-17-state-security-agency-officials-reject-obligation-to- disclose-financial-interests/
Evans, J. (2020, February 9). Thieves strike again at the State Security Agency. News24. https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/news/thieves-strike- again-at-the-state-security-agency-20200209/
Evans, S. (2019, March 11). SPY WARS: Kasrils says he warned ANC about factions using spooks. News24. https://www.news24.com/news24/SouthAfrica/News/ spy-wars-kasrils-says-he-warned-anc-about-factions-using-spooks-20190311
Franks, P. E. (2014). The crisis of the South African public service. Journal of the Helen Suzman Foundation, 74, 48–56. https://admin.hsf.org.za/publications/ focus/state-and-nation/9.the-crisis-of-the-south-african-public-service-p.pdf
Friedman, S. (2021, February 3). Zuma’s abuse of South Africa’s spy agency underscores need for strong civilian oversight. The Conversation. https:// theconversation.com/zumas-abuse-of-south-africas-spy-agency-underscores- need-for-strong-civilian-oversight-154439
Fu, P. P., & Tsui, A. S. (2003). Utilising printed media to understand desired leadership attributes in the People’s Republic of China. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 20(4), 423–446. https://doi.org/10.1023/a:1026373124564
Galeotti, M. (2020). The Presidential Administration: The Command and Control Nexus of Putin’s Russia. Security Insights, 49, 1–8. https://www.marshallcenter. org/sites/default/files/files/2020-02/SecurityInsights_44.pdf
Gookins, A. J. (2008). The role of intelligence in policy making. The Role of Intelligence in Policy Making, 28(1), 65–73. https://doi.org/10.1353/ sais.2008.0025
Goodman, M. J. (2008, March). The CIA and the perils of politicisation. International Policy Report, 1–9. http://ciponline.org/nationalsecurity/ publications/ipr/CIAPerils.pdf
Government Communications and Information Services. (2019, March). Report of the High Level Review Panel on the State Security Agency (December 2018). https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201903/high- level-review-panel-state-security-agency.pdf
Hunter, Q., Cowan, K., du Toit, P., & Wicks, J. (2021, March 11). Top spies block anti-corruption unit from seizing secret documents on ‘farm.’ News24. https:// www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/breaking-top-spies-blocks-anti- corruption-unit-from-siezing-secret-documents-on-farm-20210311-2/
Hutton, L. (2009). Intelligence and Accountability in Africa. Institute for Security Studies, 2( June), 1–4. https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/112461/ JUL09INTELLIGENCEACCOUNT.pdf
Institute for Security Studies. (2007, May 11). Submission on intelligence governance and oversight in South Africa to the Ministerial Review Commission on Intelligence by the Institute for [Comment on the article “Submission on intelligence governance and oversight in South Africa to the Ministerial Review Commission on Intelligence by the Institute for Security Studies”]. Institute for Security Studies. https://issafrica.org/amp/topics/peacekeeping-and-conflict- management/11-may-2007-iss-submission-on-intelligence-governance-and- oversight-in-south-africa-ministerial-review-commission-on-intelligence
Jafta, L. (2021, January 26). Submission of Mr L Jafta, Acting Director-General of the State Security Agency, to the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture, Corruption and Fraud in the Public Sector including Organs of State. https://www.statecapture.org.za/site/files/documents/380/Day_331_-_ YY3._ Jafta,_L_-_26.01.2021.pdf
Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence. (2010, May 12). Annual Report of the Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence (JSCI) for the financial year ended 31 March 2008, as agreed by the JSCI on 12 May 2010 and submitted in compliance of section 6 of the Intelligence Services Oversight Act, No 40 of 1994 (No. ATC100526). Parliamentary Monitoring Group. https://pmg.org.za/ tabled-committee-report/54/
Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence. (2014, August 22). Annual Report of the Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence for financial year ending 31 March 2012 (ATC140410). Parliamentary Monitoring Group. https://pmg.org. za/tabled-committee-report/54/
Kaptein, M., & Wempe, J. (2002). Three General Theories of Ethics and the Integrative Role of Integrity Theory. SSRN Electronic Journal, July, 1–52. https:// doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1940393
Kasrils, R. (2006, November 1). Ministerial Review Commission on Intelligence [Press release]. https://www.gov.za/r-kasrils-ministerial-review-commission- intelligence
Khanyile, M. B. (2021, March 11). Abuses at South Africa’s spy agency shows poor governance. There are solutions. The Conversation. https://theconversation. com/abuses-at-south-africas-spy-agency-show-poor-governance-there-are- solut Auditor-General of South Africa. (2018). Public Audit Amendment Act 5 of 2018. Pretoria, SA: Government Printers. ions-155870
Lackay, A. (2013, April 23). SARS: This is the inside story – Adrian Lackay. Politicsweb. https://www.politicsweb.co.za/news-and-analysis/sars-this-is- the-inside-story--adrian-lackay
Latham, O. (2012). Politicisation of intelligence reporting: Evidence from the Cold War. Warwick.Ac.UK. https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/seminars/ seminars/conferences/peuk12/cia_politicization_oliver_latham.pdf
Lora, E. (2007). State reform in Latin America: A silent revolution. Stanford University Press. https://publications.iadb.org/publications/english/document/ The-State-of-State-Reform-in-Latin-America.pdf
Maja, K. (2020, July 15). Meritocracy or cadre deployment? How South Africa should appoint its state leaders. Daily Maverick. https://www.dailymaverick. co.za/opinionista/2020-07-15-meritocracy-or-cadre-deployment-how- south-africa-should-appoint-its-state-leaders/
Marais, N. (2021, May 3). State Security Agency has become a source of embarrassment – it’s time for our spies to come in from the cold. Daily Maverick. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-05-03-state-security-agency- has-become-a-source-of-embarrassment-its-time-for-our-spies-to-come-in- from-the-cold/
Marrin, S. (2011). Improving Intelligence Analysis: Bridging the gap between scholarship and practice. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203810200
Marrin, S. (2013). Rethinking analytical politicisation. Intelligence and National Security, 28(1), 32–54. https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2012.749064
Mbeki, T. (2005, November 24). Address of the President of South Africa, Thabo Mbeki, at the Intelligence Services Day 10th Anniversary Awards Ceremony and Inauguration of the Wall and Garden of Remembrance: Musanda, Tshwane [Press release]. http://www.dirco.gov.za/docs/speeches/2005/mbek1125.htm
Merten(a), M. (2021, April 21). Parliament plays smoke-and-mirror games – and fails its intelligence oversight. Daily Maverick. https://www.dailymaverick. co.za/article/2021-04-22-parliament-plays-smoke-and-mirror-games-and- fails-its-intelligence-oversight-duty/
Merten(b), M. (2021, August 8). State Security Agency, fingered by Lindiwe Sisulu for “harassment” of department officials, finds itself under investigation for wiretaps. Daily Maverick. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-08- 08-state-security-agency-fingered-by-lindiwe-sisulu-for-harassment-of- department-officials-finds-itself-under-investigation-for-wiretaps/
Minister for Intelligence Services. (South Africa). (1995). White Paper on Intelligence. Available from https://www.gov.za/documents/intelligence-white- paper# [Accessed 18-03-2021].
Intelligence Services Review Commission. (South Africa). (2008, September 10). Intelligence in a Constitutional Democracy: Final Report to the Minister for Intelligence Services, the honourable Mr Ronnie Kasrils, MP. https://www. gov.uk/research-for-development-outputs/intelligence-in-a-constitutional- democracy-final-report-to-the-minister-for-intelligence-services-the-hon- mr-ronnie-kasrils-mp
Mlambo, S. (2021, January 29). Shut it down! DA pens letter requesting minister to disband “captured” spy agency. IOL News. https://www.iol.co.za/news/ politics/shut-it-down-da-pens-letter-requesting-minister-to-disband- captured-spy-agency-85ab0b71-ad0d-46de-91a7-ac2d1afac36e
Ngcukana, L. (2021, April 12). Many government employees not qualified for the positions they hold – minister discloses in parliament. City Press. https://www. news24.com/citypress/news/many-government-employees-not-qualified- for-the-positions-they-hold-minister-discloses-in-parliament-20210412
Nkosi, N. (2021, August 7). Kasrils welcomes decision to do away with intelligence ministry. IOL News. https://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/kasrils- welcomes-decision-to-do-away-with-intelligence-ministry-edf7bf4f-422f- 402c-888a-96599530d3e3
Office of the Inspector-General of Intelligence (OIGI). (2006, March 23). Executive summary of the final report on the findings of an investigation into the legality of the surveillance operations carried out by the NIA on Mr S Macozoma. Extended terms of reference report on the authenticity of the allegedly intercepted e-mails [Press release]. https://www.gov.za/ documents/executive-summary-final-report-findings-investigation-legality- surveillance-operations
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. (2011). Chapter10. Public Governance. Policy Framework for Investment. In Policy framework for investment user’s toolkit (pp. 1–37). Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. https://pdf4pro.com/view/chapter-10-public-governance- oecd-5bc0c0.html
Osifo, O. C. (2012). The Effects of Ethical Governance on Public Trust: A Comparative Analysis of Anti-Corruption Policies and Procedures in Nigeria, Ghana, and Cameroon. Acta Wasaensia, 270, 1–191. https://www.uwasa.fi/ materiaali/pdf/isbn_978-952-476-417-9.pdf
Pillar, P. R. (2010). Chapter 29: The perils of politicisation [E-book]. In L. K. Johnson (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of National Security Intelligence (pp. 1–14). https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780195375886.003.0029
Tabane, R. (2019, October 14). Security minister at war with spy chiefs. City Press. https://www.news24.com/citypress/news/security-minister-at-war-with-spy- chiefs-20191014
Tendi, B. M. (2016). State intelligence and the politics of Zimbabwe’s presidential succession. African Affairs, 115(459), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1093/afraf/adv074
Thebe, T. P. (2017). Political education for good governance in South Africa’s local government and communities. African Journal of Public Affairs, 9(5), 123–135. http://hdl.handle.net/2263/59049
Tolsi, N. (2021, February 2). A despot’s time to face democracy. Mail and Guardian. https://mg.co.za/news/2021-02-02-a-despots-time-to-face-democracy/
Tsholofelo, L. (2014, March 3). Intelligence democracy dilemma: A critical evaluation of the intelligence oversight regime in Botswana. E-International Relations. https://www.e-ir.info/2014/03/03/a-critical-evaluation-of-the- intelligence-oversight-regime-in-botswana/
Tsotetsi, D. (2021, July 22). Ramaphosa administration must act on Mufamadi report to reform state intelligence. SABC News. https://www.sabcnews.com/ sabcnews/ramaphosa-administration-must-act-on-mufamadi-report-to- reform-state-intelligence/
Twala, C. (2017). The African National Congress and the Cadre Deployment Policy in the Postapartheid South Africa: A Product of Democratic Centralisation or a Recipe for Constitutional Crisis? Journal of Social Sciences, 41(2), 159-165. https://doi.org/10.1080/09718923.2014.11893352
Udit, P. (2021, February 28). Fixing the dysfunctionality within the SSA requires going back to basics. IOL News. https://www.iol.co.za/news/opinion/fixing- the-dysfunctionality-within-the-ssa-requires-going-back-to-the-basics- d3d7dcdd-942c-4344-979f-98f6eee173cf
Venter, P. (2019). Judicial defence of constitutionalism in the assessment of South Africa’s International obligations. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 22, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2019/v22i0a6253
Visvanathan, S., Verma, K., Toh, Y., & Hwee, O. B. (2020). Understanding corporate stewardship, governance and sustainability. Stewardship Asia Centre Research Paper Series, 1, 1–44. https://www.stewardshipasia.com.sg/sites/default/ files/2020-08/01%20SAC%20Research%20Series%20Paper%201%20Nexus_ final.pdf
Younkins, E. W. (2012, May 15). Objectivist virtue ethics in business. Le Québécois Libre. http://www.quebecoislibre.org/12/120515-8.html.